Skip to main content

S.D. Florida Finds For Vessel Owner Against Necessaries Provider

In DELTA NOVEMBER, LLC. vs. BAKER, 23 Fla. L. Weekly Fed. D44a (S.D. Fla. August 22, 2011), a vessel owner entered into oral repair contract with a repairer and brought the action against the repairer alleging breach of maritime contract/warranty of workmanlike performance and breach of marine bailment, after vessel sank at its berth causing damages to its hull, machinery, appurtenances, and plaintiff's personal property. The repairer moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, improper venue, and failure to state a claim.

The facts of the case are as follows. Plaintiff Delta November, LLC (“Plaintiff”) entered into an oral contract with Defendant Richard Baker (“Defendant”) to repair the starboard engine of Defendant's vessel, the M/Y CJ, a 33-foot Chris-Craft fly bridge sportfish vessel. At the time, the vessel was docked at its home dock, Worldwide Sportsman, and connected to shore-side power. The Defendant began the repairs at Worldwide Sportsman, which is located in Islamorada, Florida, wherein the Defendant then requested permission to move the vessel from Worldwide Sportsman to a berth behind Defendant's house in Tavernier, Florida. The Plaintiff granted permission for the Defendant to shift the vessel to his own house. However, instead of moving the vessel to his own house, the Defendant shifted the vessel to a berth located behind his neighbor's house. When the Defendant shifted the vessel, he failed to reconnect shore-side power. The Defendant also failed to monitor the vessel.

While docked at the Defendant's neighbor's house, the vessel began taking on water from the shaft's packing gland. The vessel's onboard bilge pumps kept up with the intruding water until the battery life died. If the Defendant had connected the vessel to shore-side power or if he had monitored the vessel, he could have saved the vessel. Instead, the vessel sank at its berth causing damage to its hull, machinery, appurtenances, and Plaintiff's personal property. The Plaintiff also alleges that the Defendant damaged the packing gland by improperly removing the starboard engine and failed to confirm the packing gland's integrity after removing the starboard engine.

The court found that the complaint falls within admiralty jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. section 1333 because the vessel was technically capable of being used in navigation and qualifies as a vessel where it was capable of floating when defendant took possession of it, and there is no allegation that its navigation system was damaged. The court also found that venue is proper where plaintiff has alleged that damage occurred in the district where complaint was filed. The court further found that venue is proper in southern district of Florida, because this is in personam admiralty action, and defendant was properly served in the district. 

Moreover, the court found that the claim for breach of warranty of workmanlike performance in an oral contract for repair should not be dismissed for failure to state claim. The court reasoned that there was no merit to the arguments that the complaint fails to state a claim because the plaintiff failed to plead that its principal or agent entered into oral contract with defendant and secondly, because oral contracts are unenforceable in admiralty. The court found that the claim for breach of marine bailment should not be dismissed for failure to state a claim where complaint, contrary to defendant's assertion, specifically alleges that defendant had exclusive possession of vessel and property to exclusion of the plaintiff.

If you are interested in receiving a full copy of this decision, please feel free to contact me at miamipandi@comcast.net or motero@houckanderson.com.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Maritime Law--U.S. Crewmember Required to Arbitrate Claims Applying Norwegian Law

In Alberts v. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd., No. 15-14775 (11th Cir. Aug. 23, 2016), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit held that a U.S. citizen, working aboard a Royal Caribbean cruise ship is required to arbitrate his claims against Royal Caribbean.
Plaintiff, a United States citizen, worked as the lead trumpeter on a passenger Royal Caribbean cruise ship. The ship is a Bahamian flagged vessel with a home port in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Royal Caribbean, the operator of the vessel, is a Liberian corporation with its principal place of business in Florida. After plaintiff became ill while working for Royal Caribbean, he filed suit alleging unseaworthiness, negligence, negligence under the Jones Act, maintenance and cure, and seaman’s wages and penalties. Royal Caribbean moved to compel arbitration, and the district court granted the motion. This appeal presented an issue of first impression: Whether a seaman’s work in international waters on a cruise ship that calls o…

Maritime Law--Jury Hits Royal Caribbean Cruises With $20.3M Verdict for Officer's Hand Injury

In Spearman v. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Case No. 2011-023730-CA-01, a Miami-Dade County, Florida jury has awarded $20.3 million to a former crewmember of Royal Caribbean Cruises, whose hand was crushed while coming to the aid of a fellow worker during an emergency test in 2008. After a three-week trial, the jury found the Miami-based cruise company negligent in operating an unseaworthy ship and 100 percent liable for the injuries suffered by Lisa Spearman, who was working an officer on Royal Caribbean’s Voyager of the Seas.



Spearman sued the company in 2011, three years after her right hand was caught in a watertight power door during a fire-safety drill. According to her lawyers, Spearman was trying to prevent the door from closing on the ship’s nurse when her hand was pulled into a recess pocket of the sliding door and crushed. The nurse allegedly breached the company’s safety protocol when she stumbled through the door, prompting the response from Spearman.
According to allegations m…

Maritime Law--Tour Boat Captain Implicated in Tragedy Off Nicaragua

As reported in the Daily Business Review on January 25, 2016, Nicaragua's police, army and navy will investigate the captain of a tourist boat and his assistant for the deaths of 13 Costa Rican passengers killed on January 23rd when the vessel capsized in bad weather. The Reina del Caribe, Spanish for "Caribbean Queen," was carrying 33 people when it went down Saturday amid rain and strong winds as it ferried between the Corn Islands, a popular tourist destination, off Nicaragua's Caribbean coast. The Daily Business Review article can be accessed here=> Daily Business Review article.

The government clarified on the 24th that the boat was carrying 25 Costa Ricans, two Americans, two British citizens, a Brazilian and three Nicaraguans. Previous reports had said there were 32 people on board, including four Americans. All the dead were Costa Ricans.

Nicaragua's naval commander for the southern Caribbean region said the boat's captain was detained because the …